Haha you'll never get guys to agree on this thing. I've bought the issue them, stuff and Maxim have done and I always disagree with who in some cases and where in others that are on that list.
I think the Jessica Alba ranking was pretty right on. SHe was in People's 100 without make up and looked gorgeous. Same with Drew Berrymore. She should have deffinitely been on the list. Paris hilton should have in absolutely no way been anywhere in that magazine ... she is disgusting in every way.